I do believe they already answered this.
But since you were the one that pointed out this was a “key utility of Tinyman” I’ve been collecting data on that
and it does seem neither Governance nor users care much about tiny rewards enough overall.
September:
October:
November:
Now Overall, I have a relatively small amount of overall voting power, I still rank the 14th largest-gov by Tinypower, and certainly among the most active trying to drive users to do something.
Here’s the thing though:
There’s very little evidence farming rewards actually attract real liquidity to LPs. At all.
Heck you can look at SHOB’s own BOTSY pairings to see that, despite having large farming rewards involved have very little in the way of real TVL.
I mean heck, half the LP does not even bother to farm when it has a 50% return
![]()
Given how few govs actually vote, my own tinypower is quite a few times more than what’s listed.
Among the LPs I voted for last cycle, even tiny/wbtc – a new LP I set up myself doesn’t even have a 100% farming rate! About 17% don’t bother at all and the LP I’m trying to draw liquidity from gobtc/tiny has a few thousand in it and it hasn’t had a farm backing in like a year!
All it would take is those users withdrawing, flipping gobtc to wbtc, and depositing but they don’t.
Because they either don’t remember it’s locked or don’t care.
Most Govs do not care about farming rewards. At all. They just don’t. God I wish they did. I’ve fought tooth and nail BEGGING users to take some form of ownership in this platform. To just drop in once a week. More importantly, most USERS don’t care about farming LPs given the stark discrepancy between liquidity and those being used to farms.
2.8% LP lock vs farming rate.
7.4% farming.
Heck look at WBTC/tiny is a perfect case-study of how farming rewards can be used to boot-strap liquidity: with a stunningly high LP to farm ratio and almost 53% APR still struggles with less than $800 liquidity involved in it – all through that is a very, very, large improvement from the $54 or so it started with in the initial days after I set up the LP, it’s high LP-to-farming ratio is only because I’ve somewhat aggressively tried to draw attention to it.
I’ve even tried to wrangle a few other govs to vote for it and boost it’s tiny payout just to see if it’ll draw in more users.
Yet I still make up a large share of the LP myself.
![]()
Community drives LP survival, not farming rewards. Dedicated, active, members wanting to grow something together.
Governance by the data, reject the idea that farming rewards and governance rewards are the most important parts of the platform.
LPs reject by the data that farming rewards are the most important part of their survival.
There is no proof that “the end of governance rewards/farming rewards” – which isn’t even that close to coming yet, represent an existential crisis to Tinyman vs the actual real issues with have of creating an active, dedicated, committed group that will transparently and aggressively work together to build up the Tinyman platform with the goal that a stronger and more committed Governance will create a strong bedrock to build upon.
If you would like to get this on chain I suggest you re-write it, and use your socials to beg and plead to get (real) govs to show up and support it SHOB. It’s a lot of work. A LOT of work.




